This is a review of the free version of the
Feeddler Google RSS feed reader for the iPad.
Login
Upon start-up the login dialog invites you to enter your Google login and password and notes that your login credentials will only be used to authenticate with Google and that the communication is SSL encrypted. (You have to trust the developer here).
After logging in, it retrieves all your Google Reader feeds and displays in a near replication of the Google Reader order. The folders were listed in the same order while the individual feeds were listed in alphabetical order rather than my preferred order.
Interface
Feeddler's interface mimics the two-pane web-based interface of the Google Reader. Like most iPad apps, the interface changes based on the orientation of the iPad. In portrait mode, it defaults to listing all the articles in my Google feeds with banner ads across the bottom of the screen; in the Pro version, the ads are not present.
In landscape mode, it switches to a 2-pane view similar to the default Google Reader interface with the left pane (about 1/3 screen-width) containing the feeds and the right pane containing the articles and the banner ads below the articles.
You can switch to full-screen article view by tapping on an article. In this mode, the bottom of the screen contains a navigation bar with left and right arrows to go to the previous and next article in the currently selected feed and icons to
star,
like (heart),
keep unread (it was not obvious what this circle icon was for) and
email the current article. The screen can also be swiped to navigate to the next and previous article. There are no ads displayed in this mode. The title of the article can be clicked to visit the actual website with the article; this is displayed in a built-in browser without having to leave Feedler. The browser has a back and forward button in the top-left along with an
RSS button which returns you to the article in the feed. The article mode also supports pinch-to-zoom.
If you select a folder in the left pane, the pane then switches to show all the feeds in that folder. This behaviour is different than Google Reader, which displays all the articles in the folder, in the right pane. There is an arrow above the left pane to return to the subscriptions. When you return to the subscriptions, the folder you selected is not hilighted, you have to look at the top of the article pane (where the articles you finished reading remain) to check what folder you just visited.
It does have some nice touches like "Night Mode" which displays in grey on black (but the revolving ads in eye-searing bright colours, at the bottom of the page, negates the usefulness of this mode (in the free version). I blocked the ads with the folds of my blanket while reading in bed.)
There are a surprising number of customizations available by tapping the
gear icon found at the bottom of the left pane, below the subscriptions. I enabled the two-line summary which displays two lines of text from each article below the title, while in browse-mode.
Comments
I tend to read an average of 1% of articles in the feeds I subscribe to, so I mostly used Feeddler in landscape mode, giving me the ability to quickly jump from feed to feed (based on reading the two-line article summary) rather than sequentially reading the full content of the articles in a folder or feed (in portrait mode).
Score
I would rate the free Feeddler app
3 out of 4 stars. I would use Feeddler to read my Google RSS feeds.
1. Usability: ½
2. Usefulness: 1
3. Looks: 1
4. Enjoyability: ½
Suggestions
I have a few suggestions for improvement, mostly in the usability, some of which may be implemented as customizable options:
- After all the articles in a feed are marked as read, automatically return the left pane to the subscription list
- Hilight the selected feed or folder in the subscriptions pane
- In the built-in web browser, the active/inactive state of the back and forward navigation buttons in the top-left is ambiguous
- In night mode, the grey bullet, indicating articles have been read, should be a darker colour (almost blending with the background), it is currently as bright as the blue unread-article bullet.